Neither venues are cheap, and the Stardome has a significantly lower capacity than the BJCC Concert Hall. The BJCC Concert Hall can fit over 2,835 people and the maximum capacity of the Stardome is 420, which is 15% less than the concert hall.

Because of these expenses to put on the show which will end up costing around $10,000, Smiley is attempting to earn his money back. He may end up only earning less than half of what he spends.

In the past the live show was free due to everything being paid for, but this year attendees must pay $30 to get into the live show. Fans of the show and people who usually attend were bothered by this change, and they sent Smiley tweets and messages saying that they didn’t want to attend. Or at the very least they didn’t want to spend money on something that used to be free.

Smiley took to social media to address these feelings fans were having. On Oct. 21 2023 Smiley posted a video to his YouTube channel titled “To People Upset About The Magic City Classic Live Broadcast”, a ten minute video explaining why he was now charging people to attend.

“Unfortunately we had to charge because hotel rooms,” Smiley said. “You got to bring in engineers, equipment, and you got to pay musicians. It’s like a $13,000 budget. So the reason I was charging was because I was trying to make some of my money back which I was still gonna lose money anyway. I was just doing it for the people. I was doing it because the people love when “The Morning Show” comes to Birmingham and does a live show.”

Since the video was uploaded Smiley has announced that he has partnered with Birmingham Mayor Randall Woodfin to bring the live broadcast back to the BJCC in 2024. The fate of this year’s broadcast is still up in the air, as Smiley revealed in his video that if they cannot pass a threshold of people buying tickets, they will cancel the show altogether.

“If we don’t sell a certain amount of tickets in a certain amount of time, then we’ll just cancel it and go on about our day and do “The Morning Show” from the studio like we’re doing,” Smiley said. “This is not to put the radio station on blast. I don’t know what goes on at KISS and SummitMedia. They’re their own entity and “The Rickey Smiley Morning Show” is its own entity.”

He continued.

“You can talk to management over at SummitMedia, but as far as the entity of “The Rickey Smiley Morning Show”, we were just trying to do it for the people, because people love the live broadcast and they actually look forward to it. And when COVID came and we were not able to do it, that hurts, and they had a good time last year when we started back doing it. So it’s your decision. Share the video for everybody that’s talking about it, and if people decide they don’t want to go, I respect it. I love you and I appreciate you.”

On Saturday, Smiley took to social media again to announce that he’s working with Birmingham Mayor Randall Woodfin to make the live broadcast happen at the BJCC in 2024. “Mayor Randall Woodfin and the City of Birmingham presents ‘The Rickey Smiley Morning Show.’ It is absolutely free! It will be back next year. And we will have two major artists to perform plus we will have a DJ outside performing while y’all are standing in line.”